A Barnes Boy fromt the line of Edmund

Could Be John D. Barnes(Jay Dee barnes Sr.)-PA as a boy or Charles Riehl Barnes-PA, or maybe Jay Eli Barnes as a boy-MN????

The family has no further info. on this photo: Our line is Thomas and Elizabeth, Edmund and Edith Lukens John Lukens Barnes and Catherine Milne, Edmund and Varna(Abina), Charles and Laura T. Riehl, then Jay Eli Barnes and Anna Jorgensen.