Perry Abernathy (1847-1923) of Indiana, Missouri, and Kansas #2

Marlene Hudson sent me this picture. She does not know who is who, and neither do I. The only name listed on the back of the original picture is that of Perry Abernathy, whom I believe is here on the left, with his wife Melissa J. Campbell, and two of his children, Rosa, b 1883, and Daisy Ellla, b 1884, because his name was on the back of four pictures Marlene sent me, and his family was pointed out on one of them. Perry was the son of Kelam Abernathy and his second wife, Elizabeth "Betsy" Ann (Penner). On 4 Aug 1865, Perry Abernathy married Susan Ann Norval, the daughter of Parker Norval and Ann (Seely). On 21 March 1878, Perry married Melissa J. Campbell, the daughter of John Dunbar Campbell and Margaret E.(Cox). After Melissa died 17 Jan 1914, and some time before the 1920 census, Perry married a Mattie, whose surname is unknown at this time. For more information, please visit my Rootsweb site, bcarl140.

Who is the man on the right?